Kitchen Series: Countertop Surfaces Pros and Cons

August 24, 2021

countertop surfaces pros and cons

Picking back up our kitchen series this week as we have had to make some big decisions for our remodel! Today we are taking a deep dive into types of kitchen countertop surface materials. We are breaking down the pros and cons as well as price differences to consider.

We spend a lot of time in our kitchen prepping or cooking meals for our big fam. (Lord knows I need all of the motivation I can get to get in there come 5pm!) My goal is I know there will be many hours spent here in years to come, so I wasn’t about to make a speedy choice on countertops! I researched a bunch of options to weigh pros, cons, and price points before visiting some local slab yards. Below is the run down!

*Note: Costs will vary depending on the type of slab so these are based on averages including fabrication costs.

marble pros and cons

(via Eye Swoon)

Pros: A natural stone that varies in colors and designs. No two slabs are the same offering a unique design to any space. It patinas over time. The color darkens slightly and the wear looks more organic (not all people like this however). Heat resistant, so it can handle hot pans and sheets. Easy to clean. Since it is also a desirable stone, it can add to your home value due to the desirability.
Cons: Depending on the type of marble it can be more porous, which means that it can easily absorb drips, spills, and pigment from things like acids, wine, or juice if it sits too long on the surface. Time and wear can cause it to etch or scratch if not sealed every year.
Cost: $$ – $$$

Quartz countertops pros and cons

(via Andrea West Design)

Pros: Since it is a manufactured stone it is non porous, and does not need sealing. This means it is low maintenance, and easy to clean. It’s durable, stain, and heat resistant. There are many variations in design, and it can mimic the look of granite or marble and add to your home value. Due to it’s durability it often comes with a lifetime or 25 year warranty.
Cons: It can be high in price. Can chip if heavy objects fall heavily on the surface or edges, and the polymer and resin fillers are susceptible to heat damage.
Cost: $$$

quartzite pros and cons

(via Elizabeth Garrett Designs)

Pros: A natural metamorphic rock formed from sandstone, quartzite has unique natural patterns. Very durable. Easy to clean and resistant to heat.
Cons: Porous and can be susceptible to stains if not sealed. Can be higher in cost. (Ranging from $100-$200 per square foot.) It is also more limited in color options as it only ranges from light grey to white.
Cost: $$$

porcelain countertops pros and cons

(via Arrows and Bow)

Pros: A strong and durable ceramic made of dense and durable clay. Resistant to stains. Non porous and hygienic. Fabricators can add color effects through pigmented glazes which brings unique colors and patterns to a porcelain slab. (Finishes are glazed or unglazed for matte or shiny look.) Heat and scratch resistant.
Cons: The biggest drawback is that the design is not integrated throughout the slab. Fabricators print the designs on the top of the countertop slab, so the pattern doesn’t carry throughout rounded edging. It is also difficult to fabricate without chipping occurring which tends to push the price up.
Cost: $$$

Pros: A natural stone that comes in a wide range of patterns and designs. Every slab is unique. It is a very hard substance so it is heat and scratch resistant. (It can take the heat of hot pans!) It also is a desirable kitchen surface so can help home value.
Cons: Granite is porous so if not properly sealed it can absorb liquids and stain. (A poorly-sealed countertop can also harbor bacteria in its pores.) Higher cost. (Average of $100 – $250 per square foot.)
Cost: $$-$$$

soapstone kitchen countertops pros and cons

(via Heidi Callier Design)

Pros: One of the upper hands of soapstone is that it is nonporous so it is stain and heat resistant, and doesn’t require the sealing most stone surfaces do. Can add to your home value.
Cons: Limited color and style options. Requires regular sealing like other stone surfaces. It is a softer stone, so it can scratch and wear over time. (However again, some love the worn patina look!)
Cost: $$

wood kitchen countertops pros and cons

(via Morisseypol Designs)

Wood/Butcher Block
Pros: Pairs well with all design styles. Functional for cooking as you can cut directly on the surface. Easier to install than stone surfaces. A more cost effective option.
Cons: Very porous so requires proper sealing to prevent water damage, wear, and bacteria. Since it is a soft surface it is more easily damaged with dents and scratches.
Cost: $

concrete countertop pros and cons

(via French Fancy)

Pros: Since concrete is extremely hard and tough is very heat resistant and will not scratch. Installers can achieve a smooth, seamless surface. Easy to clean. You can use varying pigments or stains to achieve the color concrete you want.
Cons: Needs to be re-sealed every 1-3 years as it is a porous material and susceptible to stains. Hairline cracks occur in nearly all concrete countertops, and it tends to be pricey to purchase and install properly.
Cost: $$$

laminate kitchen countertop pros and cons

(via The Wood Grain Cottage)

Pros: One of the most budget friendly options. Since laminate is synthetically manufactured, it comes in many different styles and colors that can mimic all kinds of stone. Very low maintenance and easy to clean. Since it’s a lighter material it is easier to install which is another cost saver.
Cons: Since it is a plastic based surface it is prone to cuts, scratches, and is only mildly heat resistant. Doesn’t have the long term durability compared to stone surfaces.
Cost: $

Types of finishes:
Honed – Matte with a slight sheen
Polished – Shiny and smooth
Leathered – Matte a textured finish

Places to browse online:
Most of these places offer samples for purchase as well.

(Michelangelo calacatta marble – my favorite selection that ended up being THE most expensive of course.)

(Our final choice is this honed marble!)

What we decided on:
Marble it is! I was first under the impression that marble was the priciest material and would be out of our budget range. I am most drawn to the natural beauty of marble and how each slab is a unique piece of the earth. I was shocked to see my favorite slabs were actually lower on the cost list than quarts, quartzite, and granite! This does mean more maintenance however, and every slab yard employee will discourage you from buying if you have small children. HOWEVER! After polling the IHOD audience for real lived in experiences, soooo many of you said you actually haven’t had much problems with your marble countertops if sealed properly. I think it gets a bad rap due to the etching and scratching that can occur, but I personally love the patina look. (If you like super smooth and clean, quartz may be your best bet.) After looking at numerous options we found a honed marble slab that would fit our space and overall design really well. It will be a key element in our kitchen, so I love how it has a warmer overall feel than most slabs we looked at.

As we get down to the wire before the renovation begins, I will be sharing final renderings and plans so you can follow along in our IHOD weekly email!

What has been your countertop experiences? Which surfaces have worked for you?

Leave a Comment

  • Kristin Schleiter

    Be very careful around the sink! I didn’t mind the patina and etching that came almost immediately (housewarming party salsa), and annual sealing was easy and prevented stains. My main issue was that the edges of the sink chipped constantly from pots and pans. By the time I moved into a new place (with kid friendly quartz I appreciate with 3 littles) a few quarter-sized chunks had broken loose. Be very careful!

    • This is helpful feedback thank you Kristin! We are installing one large open sink in hopes of providing extra space for pot washing and preventing wear on edges. My two section sink now makes it feel super crammed when washing!

    • Dede Galindo

      I agree. We have quartz countertops and island. I love the durability to heat but we have chips around our sink and dishwasher.

  • We just installed leathered granite in thunder white in our kitchen remodel and we absolutely love it. We love how the stone feels raw and natural and all the veining (and the amethyst spots!) it’s like our countertops are a rock collection.

    • I saw the most beautiful leathered granite at the slab yard and was wishing the colors worked with our kitchen plan. It is such a cool surface!

  • Bethany Loosbrock

    This post was so helpful! We are talking about renovating our kitchen soon and the different types of countertops was pretty daunting to me.

    I LOVE the first one slab (of course it’s pricy)! Your choice is so classic! Can’t go wrong with that choice!

    • Anna Liesemeyer

      I am so happy to hear that! And thank you – I am really looking forward to seeing it in action soon:)

  • I have had granite and quarz for many years and there have been absolutely no issues on neither growing my family, but prefer the quarz which has remained shiny in all these years (and we do alot of baking and cooking). I had used a beautiful marble countertop in one of my bathrooms when first married which got stained and so could not think of using it in my kitchen. Traumas are not easy to overcome I guess..

  • Becca Garber

    Hooray!!! I love your choice! Is it Brazilian marble, also known as Shadow Storm? That’s what we just installed in our kitchen. The slab looks almost identical, and I also did a honed surface. I love it! And I have 5 small children. No staining yet and is so so beautiful.

  • Kendra Vinson

    I’m swooning for that Michelangelo marble!! Love tour choice too! I have some chips in my granite countertops so it can happen to that too. I say go with what you love and know some wear will happen to most surfaces.

  • Hayley Browne

    I’m so excited for you all! We need a kitchen renovation in our 120 year old house. I had been wanting marble too! Think I will go with it knowing that it’s possible to have even with small children.

    • Anna Liesemeyer

      How exciting! Will definitely be posting an update on how it holds up!

  • Thanks for this! It helped me finally make my choice of which countertop I’ll get. I’ve been browsing articles and posts for quite sometime now but the photos you had and the things you shared really weighed in.

  • This blog has made the process of selecting material for countertops so easier. The pros and cons are very clearly written. Thanks for posting this.

  • Could you give us an update on how the marble is holding up 6 months later?!

  • Cathy Lorio

    Hi, I’m helping my son decide on countertops & the most affordable & also quite beautiful is a marble called pints verde. We have been warned against it. Is your marble dolomite? (We heard this holds up much better but unfortunately the one we like isn’t that). How is it working for your family? Does it require you to be on the ball at all times when using the countertops? Thanks for your help.

  • Thank you for talking about soapstone. I’ve been trying to get some inspiration for our home now that we’re renovating our kitchen. I’ll have to look into this since it seems like it could be a good idea to invest in.

Copyright © 2024 In Honor Of Design powered by chloédigital